Is this electronic music?

[cooliofranco]

[youtubehd]WqE9zIp0Muk[/youtubehd]

[youtubehd]3RBSkq-_St8[/youtubehd]

[Lane Visitor]

Haha! Awesome..

 

imo, yes and no.

 

we need a new term for electronic music, i think- the phrase is so outdated.

[pierlu]

is this?

www.youtube.com/watch?v=VkUq4sO4LQM

(ps JAZZ!)

[luke viia]

is a singing christmas card electronic music?

[Amen Lare]

No, it's not. Then again, electronic music isn't electronic also when it's not constructed by synthesis. Any music use electronic devices for some phase of production this day.

 

Making robots to play pop rock is a good social commentary.

[luke viia]

a christmas card is totally electronic music, it's made by electronics!

 

are these quadrotors playing electronic music?

 

 

 

(answer: no, robots can play acoustic music poorly too.)

 

[Amen Lare]

a christmas card is totally electronic music, it's made by electronics!

 

I was replying to the title question, who cares if christmas car is electronic music? Is there a fan base for it?

 

edit: won't edit my christmas car

[mcbpete]

Are these birds playing electronic music -

 

 

Are these primates playing electronic music -

 

[luke viia]

 

a christmas card is totally electronic music, it's made by electronics!

 

I was replying to the title question, who cares if christmas car is electronic music? Is there a fan base for it?

 

edit: won't edit my christmas car

 

 

there's probably a market for christmas cars, but yes, i realize now that you weren't replying to me, lol. and no one has to care, i'm not even sure i do tbh

[Amen Lare]

 

 

a christmas card is totally electronic music, it's made by electronics!

 

I was replying to the title question, who cares if christmas car is electronic music? Is there a fan base for it?

 

edit: won't edit my christmas car

 

 

there's probably a market for christmas cars, but yes, i realize now that you weren't replying to me, lol. and no one has to care, i'm not even sure i do tbh

 

 

Anyway to answer your question, i think it could be done both ways - if it's a mini-recorder with a lo-fi sample of a song, then it's not electronic, if it's 1-bit programmed mechanism, then i think it could be regarded as electronic music replica. I think there is a pure electronic music, when it's synthesized from scratch, and not pure, built using electronic devices including synths and samplers. Almost all music this age is electronic to some extent and there is no clear line for definition.

 

Therefore birds and monkeys in example above aren't playing purely electronic music either. Birds in general are better at music than robots, monkeys and humans