Writing melancholic and sad melodies,a trick

[fxbip 88]

Simple trick for sad moods.

Don't use the 7th note in the minor scale.

If in A minor,don't use the G note when writing a melody.

A,B,C,D,E,F and no G.

Using this 6 note scale

Everything is instantly more melancholic.

Edited February 4, 2018 by fxbip

[Gyroscopic 17]

Allow me to interject, but the perfect insturment to use for sad songs are pianos and strings. Nothing else works as well as piano and string samples. Maybe some woodwind samples if you're feeling a bit frisky.

[sheatheman 217]

Let's take this thread to the next level and discuss how to voice major structures and how to approach them texturally to make them sad!

[Silent Member 1267]

Pitch up those vocals and make them stutter for real fake feels, like EDM superstars OPN and Coldplay.

[iococoi 2371]

 

The minor sixth is full of fear

 

http://www.willimekmusic.de/music-and-emotions.pdf

Edited February 5, 2018 by iococoi

[BCM 766]

this thread needs merging with prodoction tops

[TubularCorporation 701]

this thread needs merging with prodoction tops

 

Arrangemant taps?

[KovalainenFanBoy 247]

Pitch up those vocals and make them stutter for real fake feels, like EDM superstars OPN and Coldplay.

 

reported for OPN slander. Lopatin will be protected at all costs

[BCM 766]

a good method for writing melancholic melodies is to get a pet raven

[xox 1012]

 

Pitch up those vocals and make them stutter for real fake feels, like EDM superstars OPN and Coldplay.

 

reported for OPN slander. Lopatin will be protected at all costs

 

 

gocab, am wift ya

[auxien 2193]

Just detune the synths? Instantly melancholiaizes/sadifies any melody.

[BCM 766]

make all your synths depressed by constantly telling them you hate them

[TubularCorporation 701]

Get a Variac and run all your gear at about 15v below mains current.  It will feel run down and depressed in no time, and that will come through in the music you make with it. 

[Tim_J 1561]

make all your synths depressed by constantly telling them you hate them

lol

[Tim_J 1561]

[waldszenen 0]

Dumbest shit I ever read. But what was I expecting...

[Kavinsky 6]

hey thx for the tip !

[fxbip 88]

hey thx for the tip !

At least one person really tried it.

My pleasure man.

[sheatheman 217]

 

hey thx for the tip !

At least one person really tried it.

My pleasure man.

Cool theory behind that is the 7th of a minor scale is the dominant (5th) of that scale's relative major (the 3rd), which will briefly tether your ear to a major tonality, essentially tonicizing the 3rd. But without that dominant, the feeling of major tonality has no grounding and can't materialize.

 

So yeah, it's actually true in a theory sense.

Edited February 11, 2018 by sheathe

[yekker 995]

or just write music when your sad i guess

[fxbip 88]

 

 

hey thx for the tip !

At least one person really tried it.

My pleasure man.

Cool theory behind that is the 7th of a minor scale is the dominant (5th) of that scale's relative major (the 3rd), which will briefly tether your ear to a major tonality, essentially tonicizing the 3rd. But without that dominant, the feeling of major tonality has no grounding and can't materialize.

 

So yeah, it's actually true in a theory sense.

 

Exactly!

When writing in natural minor if you use the 7th note you add a major feel most of the time to melodies.

If you avoid it the minor feel gets more accentuated and also will sound less dark than harmonic minor that has the sharp 7th.

Thus making a real melancholic minor scale without as much major feel from the relative major or dark feel from the harmonic minor scales!

Edited February 22, 2018 by fxbip

[volterock 0]

Change your environment too. Maybe paint everything black, cut some onions with your dog, and talk / sing / bark like you're dead if you don't already feel that way.

[zoix 14]

 

 

 

hey thx for the tip !

At least one person really tried it.

My pleasure man.

Cool theory behind that is the 7th of a minor scale is the dominant (5th) of that scale's relative major (the 3rd), which will briefly tether your ear to a major tonality, essentially tonicizing the 3rd. But without that dominant, the feeling of major tonality has no grounding and can't materialize.

 

So yeah, it's actually true in a theory sense.

Exactly!

When writing in natural minor if you use the 7th note you add a major feel most of the time to melodies.

If you avoid it the minor feel gets more accentuated and also will sound less dark than harmonic minor that has the sharp 7th.

Thus making a real melancholic minor scale without as much major feel from the relative major or dark feel from the harmonic minor scales!

Great tips guys!

 

Skickat från min SM-G930F via Tapatalk

[Braintree 1519]

*starts song in a minor*

 

*punches own testicles*

 

*finishes song in f# minor*

Edited February 24, 2018 by Braintree

[thawkins 472]

I painted my dog black and it died.

 

Not sure if in the mood for music.