Jump to content

Writing melancholic and sad melodies,a trick


fxbip
 Share

Recommended Posts

Simple trick for sad moods.

Don't use the 7th note in the minor scale.

If in A minor,don't use the G note when writing a melody.

A,B,C,D,E,F and no G.

Using this 6 note scale

Everything is instantly more melancholic.

Edited by fxbip
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Pitch up those vocals and make them stutter for real fake feels, like EDM superstars OPN and Coldplay.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Pitch up those vocals and make them stutter for real fake feels, like EDM superstars OPN and Coldplay.

 

reported for OPN slander. Lopatin will be protected at all costs

 

 

gocab, am wift ya

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

hey thx for the tip !

At least one person really tried it.

My pleasure man.

Cool theory behind that is the 7th of a minor scale is the dominant (5th) of that scale's relative major (the 3rd), which will briefly tether your ear to a major tonality, essentially tonicizing the 3rd. But without that dominant, the feeling of major tonality has no grounding and can't materialize.

 

So yeah, it's actually true in a theory sense.

Edited by sheathe
Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...

 

 

hey thx for the tip !

At least one person really tried it.

My pleasure man.

Cool theory behind that is the 7th of a minor scale is the dominant (5th) of that scale's relative major (the 3rd), which will briefly tether your ear to a major tonality, essentially tonicizing the 3rd. But without that dominant, the feeling of major tonality has no grounding and can't materialize.

 

So yeah, it's actually true in a theory sense.

 

Exactly!

When writing in natural minor if you use the 7th note you add a major feel most of the time to melodies.

If you avoid it the minor feel gets more accentuated and also will sound less dark than harmonic minor that has the sharp 7th.

Thus making a real melancholic minor scale without as much major feel from the relative major or dark feel from the harmonic minor scales!

Edited by fxbip
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

 

 

hey thx for the tip !

At least one person really tried it.

My pleasure man.

Cool theory behind that is the 7th of a minor scale is the dominant (5th) of that scale's relative major (the 3rd), which will briefly tether your ear to a major tonality, essentially tonicizing the 3rd. But without that dominant, the feeling of major tonality has no grounding and can't materialize.

 

So yeah, it's actually true in a theory sense.

Exactly!

When writing in natural minor if you use the 7th note you add a major feel most of the time to melodies.

If you avoid it the minor feel gets more accentuated and also will sound less dark than harmonic minor that has the sharp 7th.

Thus making a real melancholic minor scale without as much major feel from the relative major or dark feel from the harmonic minor scales!

Great tips guys!

 

Skickat från min SM-G930F via Tapatalk

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
 Share

  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
  • Similar Content

    • By zleep
      So, as I mentioned in this thread, (yes its been a year) I made a max patch for generating melody, and now it is a standalone app called ITVL (interval).

      It is basically a generative sequencer packed into a step sequencer, you decide when the next step will be triggered and what note will be played instead of letting algorithms do it, so you have the full control and it is easy to change a single note anytime. It is like you have the generative framework but your brain will be the "algorithm".

      It is my first time to make an app and it did take a lot of time to build on my prototype, fix bugs, a bunch of stuffs were added and a lot of functions were adjusted for releasing to public.

      How do you guys think about this?
       
      It is available here

      some videos, more are coming soon.
       
      [youtubehd]LD3H8RUSFIE[/youtubehd]
       
      [youtubehd]tPg3IQRkZFw[/youtubehd]
       
       
       
    • By o00o
      Post your favorite self-composed melody and tell us about the instrument / synthesis / harmonics used and why you like it so much
    • Guest yanG
      By Guest yanG
      ideas for the second half welcome, and on overall production (drums too loud?)
       
      i'm pretty happy with the arpeggios & melody, sounds like my mood, tell me what you think!
       

       
      Edit: works better with a link!
×
×
  • Create New...