Dune

[frankbooth]

I want to believe and will definitely watch this on HBOMax. Just refuse to jump on the Villeneuve bandwagon. Seen everything he’s done down to the shorts and just find it all so self important. There are soMe great reviews outta Venice. But look at David Ehrlich’s review, which goes into depth about how it doesn’t have a pulse

Lynch disowns his version, but until proven otherwise that’s the Dune for me.

Also fwiw Chase Palmer adapted Dune for WB about 15 years back and wrote a fantastic script.

[fumi]

This will do less well than even BladeRunner 2049. I think it will be loved by critics and hardcore fans but everyone else will like meh. I’m still looking forward to it but part 2 will depend on the cash tills ringing big time - I can’t see that happening. It’s niche, cult sci-fi and that didn’t work out so well for the director last time.

[Rubin Farr]

7 hours ago, fumi said:

This will do less well than even BladeRunner 2049. I think it will be loved by critics and hardcore fans but everyone else will like meh. I’m still looking forward to it but part 2 will depend on the cash tills ringing big time - I can’t see that happening. It’s niche, cult sci-fi and that didn’t work out so well for the director last time.

Yeah they’re overestimating it’s appeal to the American public, like Blade Runner 2049. It’s got the nerdverse all excited, but the general public has a lot of crises now to distract them, so I bet most will stream, if they even watch it. Since a sequel is still dependent on profitability of the first film, reviews say it spends too much time setting up a 3rd act that never comes. I’ve got an nice sized telly, so streaming, popcorn and a bong for me, thank you garçon.  

[thumbass]

Started reading God Emperor of Dune after a 1.5 year long break from the boom series. Excited to get back into it!

[In C]

All this Dune fuss led to me watching the 3-hour fan edit of the 80s movie. Objectively speaking it's still a terrible film but I've done much stupider and less worthwhile things in 3 hours.

[Rubin Farr]

 

[exitonly]

dope interview. also, that scarf is out of control

[Rubin Farr]

 

[J3FF3R00]

On 9/17/2021 at 10:23 AM, nikisoko said:

dope interview. also, that scarf is out of control

Something tells me he’s a Dr. Who fan. 

[gnarlybog]

Also diving into God Emperor of Dune to keep the high from seeing this movie going. Part 2 Part 2!

[ignatius]

someone saw it and posted on twitter that the score is super over th etop hanz zimmemememerrr

still will see it though 

[azatoth]

Was good half a movie. Now just get part 2 done,pls. Liked the aesthetics, this part seemed more like a setup of the setting and the players for the proper second movie. The ususal Zimmer zwap-boom type of soundtrack. Can the man still compose melodic themes? Rebecca Fergusson

Edited September 19, 2021 by azatoth

[Squee]

Man, that was boring. 

[Rubin Farr]

8 hours ago, ignatius said:

someone saw it and posted on twitter that the score is super over th etop hanz zimmemememerrr

still will see it though 

Wasn’t that how Blade Runner 2049 was? Sometime the music was so loud you couldn’t hear the dialogue in the theater.

[Frank Poole]

18 hours ago, ignatius said:

someone saw it and posted on twitter that the score is super over th etop hanz zimmemememerrr

still will see it though 

Would have been a great job for Jóhann Jóhannsson

Edited September 20, 2021 by Frank Poole
Spelling

[Rubin Farr]

58 minutes ago, Frank Poole said:

Would have been a great job for Jóhann Jóhannsson

I’d like to hear Clint Mansell take a whack at soundtracking Dune.

 

btw, you guys ever heard Rupert Lally's Dune soundtrack? Came out on Bibliotapes a few years back:

[realthanks]

not sure if it's already been mentioned ITT, but Jodorowsky's Dune is an awesome watch

 

[Rubin Farr]

I’m not sure how many of you have seen the 2000s version from Syfy, but it might be the only adaptation of God Emperor and Children of Dune we see on screen for quite a while, unless they did the entire saga on television again, which might be a better approach since the source material of Dune is so expansive.

[Cryptowen]

On 9/20/2021 at 5:38 PM, realthanks said:

not sure if it's already been mentioned ITT, but Jodorowsky's Dune is an awesome watch

yeah i watched that a few years back and it made me pretty hype about the creative process in general. remember it having a good soundtrack as well.

Spoiler

unfortunately anyone i've mentioned it to irl just fixates on the one part where Jodorowsky compares making art to deflowering a hesitant bride

 

[may be rude]

On 9/19/2021 at 12:29 PM, azatoth said:

Was good half a movie. Now just get part 2 done,pls. Liked the aesthetics, this part seemed more like a setup of the setting and the players for the proper second movie. The ususal Zimmer zwap-boom type of soundtrack. Can the man still compose melodic themes? Rebecca Fergusson

 

hmm cool. just learning it's half the book. i had been wondering how they would fit the book in film length, so i'm glad they aren't gutting it.

 

i was preventing myself from hype because br 2049 was weird. i'm starting to think dune may be about as good of a dune as we could hope for, based on what i'm seeing.

 

 

got to wait because it doesnt release yet in states

 

[NewSchoolScience]

People dissing BR2049.  Deary me.

[chim]

Looks like a snorefest. 

[Soloman Tump]

I really enjoyed BR2049, and I have a ticket to see Dune at an IMAX.  

First cinema trip in ages... cant remember what I last saw.  

[dcom]

Saw Dune in the theatre today, loved it, regardless that it's part one - so yes, half of the story with a hard to-be-continued ending - and part two starts filming 2022 at the earliest. I loved Villeneuve's Blade Runner, too, but my favourite from his oeuvre is still Arrival (although Ted Chiang's short story Story of Your Life it's based on is even better - all of his stories are amazing). Haters gonna hate, and there are always those who love to be Dementors towards others' pleasure - "I don't like it so you're stupid."

Edited September 23, 2021 by dcom

[jaderpansen]

Hey yo so this was... pretty adequate actually!

Didn't read the books but from what i've heard it was quite a faithful adaption. Turns out some stuff i missed was entirely Lynch's idea lol. Ah well whatevs. While i always felt the Lynch version starts out well enough and only really starts falling apart in the second half, this one was pretty much the other way around, got better once shit got down on Arrakis.

My fav scene was the one with Paul and Jessica being tied up on the Ornithopter... actually i think Ferguson's performance was my favourite overall.

Hoping for pt 2 now. Peace.