Jump to content
IGNORED

JAZZ - THE THREAD


halisray

Recommended Posts

  • Replies 1.2k
  • Created
  • Last Reply

Top Posters In This Topic

that tune is pretty straight-ahead

not much syncopation in the rhythm section

very "4/4"

which would probably classify it as 'swing'

which was the dominant strain of jazz in the 20's 30's and early 40's

early 'bebop' was conservative in that way too

though a bit more syncopated

 

i'm not sure when that tune's actually from

the sound quality seems more 50's than 30's

Edited by LimpyLoo
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest murphythecat8

that is like in the transition from cool jazz to hard bop. definitely a recording from at least the 50's, my guess is mid 50's

Edited by murphythecat8
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest murphythecat8

 

I'll check out your guitar list, Murphy the cat.

well they are all classics by now. the joe pass is for real maniacs fan who like to really try to understand the solo.

wes, kenny and grant green and much more accessible.

Edited by murphythecat8
Link to comment
Share on other sites

Joe Pass is indeed virtuosic but he's a bit of a lick machine

 

the problem with the history of jazz guitar

 

is that pretty much all the guitarists lagged behind the horn players and pianists in the chops department

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest murphythecat8

Joe Pass is indeed virtuosic but he's a bit of a lick machine

 

the problem with the history of jazz guitar

 

is that pretty much all the guitarists lagged behind the horn players and pianists in the chops department

I dont see and hear any problem with joe pass, his virtuosic lines are so virtuosic that I love it, but its for real maniacs I guess.

 

pretty much all the guitarist? not my opinion, Wes, Green, Metheny, Burell all hold their own as much as horn players but I agree that guitar jazz has much less top/original players then horns or piano players.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

Joe Pass is indeed virtuosic but he's a bit of a lick machine

 

the problem with the history of jazz guitar

 

is that pretty much all the guitarists lagged behind the horn players and pianists in the chops department

I dont see and hear any problem with joe pass, his virtuosic lines are so virtuosic that I love it, but its for real maniacs I guess.

 

pretty much all the guitarist? not my opinion, Wes, Green, Metheny, Burell all hold their own as much as horn players but I agree that guitar jazz has much less top/original players then horns or piano players.

 

 

Metheny is where the guitarists start catching up in chops imo.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest murphythecat8

 

 

Joe Pass is indeed virtuosic but he's a bit of a lick machine

 

the problem with the history of jazz guitar

 

is that pretty much all the guitarists lagged behind the horn players and pianists in the chops department

I dont see and hear any problem with joe pass, his virtuosic lines are so virtuosic that I love it, but its for real maniacs I guess.

 

pretty much all the guitarist? not my opinion, Wes, Green, Metheny, Burell all hold their own as much as horn players but I agree that guitar jazz has much less top/original players then horns or piano players.

 

 

Metheny is where the guitarists start catching up in chops imo.

 

I agree, BUT not all Metheny album are born equal. He has one of the most large discography of jazz guitarist, the biggest actually.

you have to know what to listen from him, otherwise you are lost

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest murphythecat8

For 2 years, Ive listen to 100% jazz all the time. I had gave up on electronica and well I can say I know my jazz.

Metheny is the most intimate, most emotional player out there. For non jazz fan, he is THE guitarist to listen. he is able to take jazz and turn it into something more accessible, while staying in the tradition. A genius imo.

 

heres a top 5 metheny:

 

Bright size life

Watercolors

Rejoicing

Questions and answer
trio live

 

I could also make a top 5 of Green or Wes if anyones interested!

Edited by murphythecat8
Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

 

 

Joe Pass is indeed virtuosic but he's a bit of a lick machine

 

the problem with the history of jazz guitar

 

is that pretty much all the guitarists lagged behind the horn players and pianists in the chops department

I dont see and hear any problem with joe pass, his virtuosic lines are so virtuosic that I love it, but its for real maniacs I guess.

 

pretty much all the guitarist? not my opinion, Wes, Green, Metheny, Burell all hold their own as much as horn players but I agree that guitar jazz has much less top/original players then horns or piano players.

 

 

Metheny is where the guitarists start catching up in chops imo.

 

I agree, BUT not all Metheny album are born equal. He has one of the most large discography of jazz guitarist, the biggest actually.

you have to know what to listen from him, otherwise you are lost

 

 

echh yeah

 

he does a lot of smooth weather-channel shit

i'm really just referring to his facility on the instrument

not the quality of his music

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

heres a top 5 metheny:

 

Bright size life

Watercolors

Rejoicing

Questions and answer

trio live

 

i agree except for Watercolors

dunno what i'd put there though

To me Wes going Bossa Nova is the best out there. So chill

 

yeah then he went pop and did shit like "California Dreaming" lol

Link to comment
Share on other sites

Guest murphythecat8

 

 

heres a top 5 metheny:

 

Bright size life

Watercolors

Rejoicing

Questions and answer

trio live

 

i agree except for Watercolors

dunno what i'd put there though

 

80/81 then?

Watercolors is really a personnal record album for me. Its right when I began my journey into jazz.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

 

 

 

heres a top 5 metheny:

 

Bright size life

Watercolors

Rejoicing

Questions and answer

trio live

 

i agree except for Watercolors

dunno what i'd put there though

 

80/81 then?

Watercolors is really a personnal record album for me. Its right when I began my journey into jazz.

 

 

I would pick that Michael Brecker record with "Song for Bilboa"

Link to comment
Share on other sites

I just mean generally speaking.

 

Django had a rhythmic rigor and harmonic knowledge (aka an ability to "play the changes") that surpasses most guitar players, two qualities which are mostly found in horn players. I'm not criticizing specific players so much as I'm pointing out that jazz guitar as a discipline was late to bloom, and if you picked up a guitar in 1960 with the intention of playing jazz, there wasn't a clear, well-trodden path ahead of you and a body of guitar-related academia to study behind you. If you want to find precedent for a guitarist like Wes Montgomery you gotta look to tenor players, not guitar players. For instance, even a genius like Wes had a rather limited harmonic vocabulary as far as actual voicings go. If you look at his chord-melody transcriptions you see drop-2 voicings and variations thereof, and that's it.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

The generation after Wes, however, is where guitarists in general started to catch up a little bit. You had dudes like Pat Martino and Pat Metheny who could burn over changes like "Giant Steps," a feat that pretty much no guitarists before them could accomplish. And I'm not talking about speed so much as I'm talking about being able to play the changes.

Link to comment
Share on other sites

  • 2 weeks later...
  • 2 weeks later...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
  • Recently Browsing   0 members

    • No registered users viewing this page.
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.